Water-Resistant Treated Leather Work Shoes vs Waterproof Membrane: What’s the Difference?
Two types of leather work shoes can protect you from the elements: those made with water-resistant treated leather and those equipped with a waterproof membrane. Each technology has its specific advantages, designed to meet different needs. Here's a comparison to help you find the perfect pair!
1. Materials and Protection
Water-resistant treated leather work shoes (boots or safety shoes) are made from high-quality natural leather, specially treated and with sealed seams to repel water and protect against splashes or short-term exposure to the elements. This treatment maintains the flexibility and elegance of the leather while providing good moisture resistance. They're ideal for workers who wear their shoes both indoors and outdoors.
Boots with a waterproof membrane, on the other hand, have an internal waterproof barrier (like Drylock), providing superior protection against water. This internal membrane ensures that your feet stay dry even in particularly wet environments or during prolonged exposure to water.
Also, note that at Acton, unlike some other brands, all work shoes with a waterproof membrane also have treated leather to enhance performance and longevity.
2. Breathability and Comfort
The leather in water-resistant shoes is not only resistant to water but also naturally breathable, promoting optimal ventilation. This makes them an ideal choice for those seeking both comfort and durability in moderately wet conditions.
Waterproof membrane boots focus on water resistance. The breathability of membrane shoes can vary depending on the performance of the membrane. Higher-performance membranes (Drylock II vs. Drylock I) are more expensive but optimize breathability, allowing perspiration to escape more easily, keeping your feet drier and more comfortable even during prolonged activities. Waterproof membrane boots are perfect for workers exposed to more water or working outdoors.
3. Easy Maintenance and Durability
Water-resistant leather shoes are designed to make cleaning easy from salt, mud, and dirt, and to increase resistance to daily wear caused by moisture and contaminants. Daily cleaning and drying can prolong the life of the shoes while maintaining their hydrophobic properties. Since the leather is already treated, no waterproofing product is recommended, although wax can be applied to keep the leather supple and looking good.
Waterproof membrane boots require little maintenance. The internal membrane remains effective in wetter conditions, providing longer-lasting protection. Wax can also be applied to preserve the quality and appearance of the leather.
Whether they have a waterproof membrane or not, cleaning your safety shoes with a damp cloth and mild soap and regularly air drying them will extend their lifespan.
Both water-resistant leather shoes and those with a membrane may lose their effectiveness over time. The leather’s protection will eventually wear down, and the waterproof membrane will lose performance after many flexes, so don’t be surprised by this.
4. Adaptability to Conditions
Water-resistant leather shoes are perfect for workers who need a versatile pair, ideal for both indoor and outdoor use in moderately wet conditions. They offer a balance between protection and everyday comfort.
For more demanding work environments, like wet construction sites or rainy days, waterproof membrane boots are the ideal solution. They’re designed to withstand the elements and keep your feet dry.
In Summary
If you want to maximize breathability and comfort in your safety shoes, and you have limited exposure to water, opt for shoes with treated leather. Treated leather also makes cleaning easier and improves durability.
If you want to maximize waterproofing and performance in the face of the elements, choose work boots with a waterproof membrane. For more comfort, go for a breathable waterproof membrane (like Drylock II).
For optimal protection against prolonged exposure to water, nothing beats a pair of rain boots with a protective toe cap and sole.
Acton has the perfect solution for every worker!